Commentary: Wakeboats can responsibly co-exist with other forms of Minnesota boating
I recently read Bob Zink’s article, “Should we leave wakeboats in our wake?” (Outdoor News, Dec. 5, 2025), and while I appreciate anyone taking an interest in lake health, the conclusions presented deserve a more careful, science-grounded response.
As a recreational boater and wake-surfing enthusiast, I believe we all share the same goal: to keep our lakes healthy while ensuring they remain accessible for everyone – not just those who live on the shoreline.
The article paints wake surfing as uniquely harmful, yet many of its claims rely on limited or selectively interpreted studies. The University of Minnesota video cited in the story shows controlled test passes at a fixed 14-foot depth – conditions that do not reflect how responsible wake-sport operators actually use our lakes. In reality, riders seek deeper water and open areas because that’s where wakes perform best.
Just as importantly, the article repeats generalizations – such as wakeboats disturbing the lake bottom “times 10” – without offering standardized measurements or hydrodynamic analysis. Other large boats, including cruisers, pontoon boats with high-horsepower outboards, and larger stern-drive boats, can produce prop wash and wake energy similar to or greater than many wakeboats. Singling out one category without context does not advance an honest conversation.
